SimHistory.org
Arguing History · Teacher's guide

The Haymarket Trial, 1886

A courtroom for practicing claim, evidence and analysis. You are the judge. A few students argue for the prosecution or the defense; everyone else is the jury, rating each argument like an AP reader and deciding the verdict.

4 roundsone question each
2 periodsSave and open the next day
4 levelsreading levels by join code

Before you play

Spanish on student screens. Students can pick Español as their reading level, or you can give them a code ending in -ES. The case, evidence, choices and screens switch to Spanish; exact words from 1886 stay in English, in quotation marks. Your screen and the projector stay in English. (Machine-assisted translation; a native speaker review is planned.)

Content note. The case involves a bombing that killed police officers and civilians, and the execution of four of the defendants (a fifth died in his cell). Nothing is shown graphically. Students argue as lawyers or judge as jurors; no one plays the defendants, the police or the bomber.

History to know. In the 1880s many industrial workers, a large share of them immigrants, worked 10 to 12 hours a day. A national movement for an eight-hour day called for strikes on May 1, 1886, centered in Chicago, where a small anarchist movement published papers urging workers to resist employers and police. Many Americans feared radicals and immigrants. That's all students need; the game gives the rest round by round.

Who sees what

Your screen (the judge)

  • Join codes, one per reading level
  • What to say at every step
  • The answer key for each round
  • Objections with advice: what to rule, what Judge Gary did in 1886, and how lawyers see it today
  • Seats, ratings, scores, Save game and results

The projector

  • The join code and the case file
  • Each round's question and shared evidence
  • Both arguments, at the reading level you choose
  • Objections you choose to show, with the student's argument and your ruling
  • The verdict, one defendant at a time, then the real history
  • Never the key or your advice

Students' devices

  • Lawyers: their exhibits, the claim–evidence–analysis builder, teammates' picks, the Object button
  • Jurors: the evidence, then a Weak/Fair/Good/Strong rating for each part of each argument, then a private vote on each man
  • Their own reading level
  • A certificate PDF at the end, made on the device

Run of show

  1. Before class10 minutes
    • Try the side-by-side demo once.
    • Open Run it with my class, choose 1 or 3 lawyers per side, and open the courtroom. The computer argues any side with no student lawyers, so a small class can be all jury.
  • The court opensDay 1 · 10 min
    • Students go to simhistory.org/haymarket and type the code for their reading level. They may volunteer to be a lawyer.
    • Click Pick lawyers (volunteers first, then at random). Click a seat to change its role.
    • Read the opening line under You say, and show the case file on the projector.
  • Each round15–20 min
    • Build (about 8 min): lawyers choose a claim, two pieces of evidence and an analysis. With three lawyers, each part is what most of them pick; the lead tells you when they are ready. Jurors read the shared evidence.
    • Present: both arguments appear on the projector. Have each side's lead read theirs aloud. Jurors rate each part.
    • Objections: a lawyer may object once a round, choosing grounds and typing a short argument. Show it on the projector, let them argue out loud, then rule. Your screen gives advice, but the score follows the key, not your ruling.
    • Scores: close the arguments to show each side's points.
  • End of Day 1after round 2
    • Click Save game. The file stays on your computer.
    • Day 2: Open saved game, students rejoin with the same code, and you pick lawyers again.
  • The verdictDay 2 · 20 min
    • Jurors vote in private on each of the eight: not guilty, guilty with prison, or guilty with death. As in 1886 Illinois, a verdict must be unanimous; otherwise it is a hung jury.
    • Click Read the verdict and reveal the men one at a time on the projector.
    • Then show What really happened, debrief, and have students download their certificates.
  • Scoring

    • Lawyers earn up to 15 a round: claim (4), two pieces of evidence (3 each), analysis (3) and an objection with merit (2). They are scored on the argument, not on winning.
    • Jurors earn up to 6 a round for rating each part of each argument close to the key, the way AP readers check their scoring. Their verdicts are never scored.
    • Results (by seat, never by name) download as a CSV on your computer.

    Reading levels. The plain CODE lets each student choose. A suffix fixes the level on that student's device: CODE-L1050 (grades 11–12, about 1050L), CODE-L850 (grades 9–10, about 850L), CODE-L600 (grades 6–8, about 600L), CODE-OR (original 1886 wording) and CODE-ES (Spanish). Post a different code to each group (in Google Classroom, say); the projector shows only the plain code, so no one sees who has which level. Lexile values are estimates from this case's text. Students see grade labels, not Lexile numbers. The projector level is set on your screen. Scores and the key are the same at every level.

    Privacy

    Students never sign in. Your screen shows them only as seats ("Juror 4"). Their devices send only their choices, ratings, votes and any objection they type; nothing is stored on a server. A student types their name only into their own certificate, on their device. Saved games and results stay on your computer.

    Accuracy

    Quotations are exact words from the trial record, Judge Gary's instructions and Governor Altgeld's 1893 pardon, with their sources in the game. Claims and analyses are written for the game from the two sides' real arguments. Where the 1886 record has no ruling on an objection, the key says so.