SimHistoryArguing History · The Haymarket Trial, 1886

How to play

You are a lawyer in the 1886 trial of eight Chicago anarchists. Choose the prosecution or the defense. The computer plays the other side, the judge and the jury.

  1. Read the evidence. Everyone sees the shared evidence. Your side also has its own exhibits (marked in gold).
  2. Build your argument: choose a claim, the two pieces of evidence that best support it, and the analysis that explains how the evidence proves the claim.
  3. Listen to the other side, and object if their argument is unfair.
  4. Watch the jury. You score points for strong arguments and good objections, not for winning.
  5. Four rounds, then the verdict on each of the eight men, your own verdicts, and what really happened. You finish with one PDF: your certificate and your answers.

Choose a reading level at the top. The facts, choices and scores are the same at every level; only the wording changes. Exact words from 1886 appear in quotation marks with their source.

Sources