Download PDFOpen the game
SimHistory · Student worksheet · Arguing History

The Haymarket Trial, 1886: Argument builder

Name
Period
My side or role

For each round, write your argument in your own words: a claim that answers the question, the two pieces of evidence that best support it, and your analysis (this shows… because…). These are the same moves as an AP DBQ or LEQ.

Round 1: The call to the meeting

Was the Haymarket meeting called to start violence?

Claim
Evidence 1
Evidence 2
Analysis: how the evidence proves the claim
The other side's weakest point

Round 2: In the square

Who started the violence in Haymarket Square?

Claim
Evidence 1
Evidence 2
Analysis: how the evidence proves the claim
The other side's weakest point

Round 3: The bombs and the plan

Do the bombs and the Monday night meeting tie the defendants to the Haymarket bomb?

Claim
Evidence 1
Evidence 2
Analysis: how the evidence proves the claim
The other side's weakest point

Round 4: Closing arguments

Should these eight men be convicted of murder?

Claim
Evidence 1
Evidence 2
Analysis: how the evidence proves the claim
The other side's weakest point

The verdict

DefendantMy verdictThe evidence that decided it
August Spies
Samuel Fielden
Albert Parsons
Michael Schwab
Adolph Fischer
George Engel
Louis Lingg
Oscar Neebe

Was the trial fair?

Use one piece of evidence and one of the judge's rulings or instructions.

© 2026 Isaac Newman. SimHistory™. Teachers may print and copy this worksheet for their classes.