Arguing History: The Haymarket Trial, 1886
Choose one plan
Plan A (free): every student argues the case alone on their own device against the computer. Plan B (Teacher Plus): the class courtroom: you are the judge, a few students are lawyers, everyone else is the jury. The worksheet is free with either plan.
Content note
This activity involves a bombing that killed police officers and civilians, and the execution of four of the defendants (a fifth died in his cell). Nothing is shown graphically; deaths are reported as history. Students argue for the prosecution or the defense as lawyers; no one plays the defendants, the police or the bomber.
History to know before you play
In the 1880s many American industrial workers, a large share of them immigrants, worked 10 to 12 hours a day, six days a week. A national movement for an eight-hour day called for strikes to begin on May 1, 1886, and Chicago was its center. A small but vocal anarchist movement, much of it German-speaking, published newspapers there and called for workers to resist employers and police. Many Americans feared radicals and immigrants. Students need only this much; the game gives the rest round by round.
Overview
On May 4, 1886, a bomb exploded among police breaking up a labor meeting near Haymarket Square in Chicago. Eight anarchists were tried for murder, though no one claimed any of them threw it. Students argue the case for the prosecution or the defense in four rounds, each a single question. In every round they build an argument from a claim, two pieces of evidence from the trial record, and the analysis that ties them together: the same moves as the AP DBQ and LEQ. They may object to the other side's argument. A jury then decides each man's fate, and the class compares its verdicts with the real ones and with Governor Altgeld's 1893 pardon.
Reading levels. Every claim, piece of evidence and analysis comes in four versions: the original words (quoted exactly, with sources), grades 11–12 (the standard), grades 9–10 and grades 6–8 (about 1050L, 850L and 600L; estimates from the text). A Spanish version is on student screens too. Facts, choices and scores are the same at every level.
Objectives
Students will be able to:
- Explain the causes and results of the Haymarket affair, including the eight-hour movement, the McCormick shooting and the 1886 fear of anarchism.
- Build an argument from a defensible claim, relevant evidence and analysis that explains how the evidence supports the claim.
- Judge the strength of others' arguments and recognize unfair ones (objections).
- Evaluate whether the trial was fair, using the conspiracy instruction, jury selection and witness credibility.
Standards
Plan A · Free: solo practice (about 45 minutes)
Show the case file (on the game's start screen). Ask: "Can words make someone guilty of murder?" Take a quick show of hands, and save the answer for the end.
Students open simhistory.org → The Haymarket Trial → Play free, choose a side and a reading level. To fix a level for a class, share the link ending in #level-m (grades 9–10), #level-e (grades 6–8) #level-o (original wording) or #level-es (Spanish). Hand out the worksheet.
Students build an argument each round, record it on the worksheet, choose an objection, and read the judge's ruling and their score. Circulate: ask "How does that evidence prove your claim?"
Students give their own verdicts, read what really happened, and answer the debrief questions. They download one PDF (certificate first, then answers) to hand in.
Plan B · Teacher Plus: the class courtroom (about two periods; in preview)
Open Run it with my class. Choose 1 or 3 lawyers per side. Read the teacher's guide and try the side-by-side demo once.
Students join at simhistory.org/haymarket with the code; give each student the code for their reading level (CODE-L1050, -L850, -L600, -OR or -ES; the plain code lets them choose). Click Pick lawyers. Read the opening line on your screen. Show the case file on the projector.
Each round: lawyers build (8 min) while jurors read the evidence; present both arguments (the projector shows them); jurors rate each part; take objections and rule using your screen's advice; show the scores. Save game at the end of the period.
Open saved game; students rejoin with the same code and you pick lawyers again (new lawyers are fine). Run rounds 3 and 4.
Jurors vote in private on each of the eight men (unanimity required, as in 1886). Read the verdicts one at a time on the projector, then show what really happened. Students download their certificates and answer the debrief.
Debrief questions
- Which piece of evidence did the most for your side, and why?
- Judge Gary told the jury the defendants were guilty even if the bomb thrower was never identified. Was that fair? Use evidence from the trial.
- Compare your class's verdicts with the real ones. What explains the differences?
- Governor Altgeld pardoned the three men still in prison in 1893. Do you agree with his reasons?
- Return to the hook: can words make someone guilty of murder? How would Brandenburg v. Ohio (1969) answer?
Model answers (for norming)
Three sample answers to debrief question 2, "Judge Gary told the jury the defendants were guilty even if the bomb thrower was never identified. Was that fair?" Use them to calibrate scoring, or show them to students and have them score each one. Written for the game; not quotations.
Developing
"It wasn't fair because they didn't know who threw the bomb. You can't punish people if you don't know who did it."
Why: a defensible claim, but no evidence from the trial and no reasoning beyond restating the claim.
Proficient
"It wasn't fair. Judge Gary's instruction let the jury convict all eight without the State linking any of them to the bomb thrower. Even the State's witness Waller said 'there was nothing said about the Haymarket' at the Monday night meeting, and most of the defendants weren't in the square. So the men were really convicted for their speeches and writings."
Why: a clear claim, two pieces of specific evidence (the instruction and Waller), and reasoning that explains how they support it.
Advanced
"The instruction followed Illinois conspiracy law as the court read it in 1886, which is why the Illinois Supreme Court upheld it, but it was still unfair. The State showed that some defendants urged violence (the 'Revenge' circular) and that Lingg made bombs, yet it never connected either to the person who threw this bomb, and Waller said the plan wasn't about the Haymarket. Convicting men for words with no link to the act punished their beliefs, which is why Altgeld pardoned the survivors in 1893 and why, under Brandenburg v. Ohio (1969), speech can be punished only when it aims at imminent lawless action."
Why: it weighs the strongest evidence on the other side, uses several sources, and places the trial in a longer legal context (the AP "complexity" point).
Answer key
The strongest argument for each side in each round, with the best objection. The game scores claim (0–4), evidence (0–3 each, two pieces), analysis (0–3) and a strong objection (2): 15 a round.
Rubric (AP-aligned)
| Skill | In the game | Strong (AP point earned) | Developing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thesis / claim | Claim choice (0–4) | Chooses the defensible claim that answers the round's question (4). | Chooses a claim that is true but does not answer the question (2), or an overreaching claim (0). |
| Evidence | Two pieces (0–6) | Both pieces directly support the claim (5–6). | One piece supports it, or the evidence is only background (1–4). |
| Analysis and reasoning | Analysis (0–3) | Explains how the evidence proves the claim (3). | Restates the evidence or argues from emotion (0–1). |
| Sourcing / complexity | Objections (0–2); juror ratings | Identifies the real weakness in the other side's evidence (credibility, missing context, misstated law). | Objects on grounds that do not apply, or not at all. |
Jurors in Plan B earn up to 6 points a round for rating each part of each argument close to the key, the way AP readers check their scoring against an answer key. Their verdicts are never scored.
Accuracy notes
- Quotations are exact words from the trial record, the State's closing (as quoted in defense lawyer Black's affidavit), Judge Gary's instructions and Governor Altgeld's 1893 pardon. The three adapted reading levels are paraphrases and never appear in quotation marks.
- The claims and analyses are written for the game from the two sides' real arguments; they are not quotations.
- The computer jury's lean in solo practice is a game rule: it starts tilted toward the prosecution because the 1886 jury was chosen by a special bailiff, not at random.
- The number of deaths is given as approximate: sources count seven or eight police officers, and an unknown number of civilians.
- Where the 1886 record has no ruling on an objection, the judge's key says so, and gives a modern view instead.