SimHistory.org
Live Debate · Teacher's guide

How to make the call

After every possession you make one call. Tick what the offense did and what the rebuttal knocked out; the ball moves that far. Practice on four real possessions from a New Deal debate, then compare your call with the original referee's.

The scoring in one minute

+30Clear claim: one point that answers the prompt
+30Evidence: facts, numbers or quotes that support it
+20Cited source: the evidence says where it came from
−The rebuttal takes back the yards of anything it knocks out

Every drive starts at the offense's own 20. All three (80 yards) is a touchdown (6); an Interview answered well adds the extra point (1). Inside the 30 (50+ yards) is a field goal (3). Anything less is stopped (a punt). You can always override: an interception (the rebuttal proves the evidence false: 6 for the defense) or a fumble (the argument contradicts the team's own case). A conclusion that answers an earlier rebuttal is a two-point conversion.

Flags move the ball: unsportsmanlike conduct (a personal attack, 15 yards), illegal use of evidence (a fact with no source, 10), delay of game (not ready, 5). Challenge flags come from each side's Booth Reviewers with proof attached: if you uphold one, the other side loses the yards for its evidence and source.

Make each call quickly at the call step; save your longer critique for the After-Game Show, where you can reopen any call.