Download PDFTeacher's guideRun the inquiry
SimHistory · Lesson plan · For the teacher

Broad Street Inquiry

Soho, London, 1854: finding the source of a cholera outbreak with John Snow's map
Grades 9–12adaptable for 6–8
45–60 minone class period
World HistoryGeography · Science & Health
Freeno student accounts
Everything in this lesson is free. Broad Street Inquiry is SimHistory's free class activity: the teacher's desk, students joining on their own devices, the projector map, the worksheet and this plan. No Teacher Plus needed.

Overview

In late August and early September 1854, cholera killed hundreds of people in a few streets of Soho, London. Students act as investigators with the evidence Dr. John Snow used. The teacher's desk controls a shared map of Snow's district. Each round, students study the map, answer questions, suggest what evidence to add, and mark the place they suspect. The teacher reveals evidence in response, until the class can name the source of the outbreak and prove it.

The lesson is a case study in the urban growth of the Industrial Revolution and in historical reasoning: forming hypotheses, testing them against new evidence, telling a pattern from a cause, and arguing from evidence.

Learning objectives

Students will be able to:

  1. Describe how crowded industrial cities such as London depended on shared water and drainage, and why that made outbreaks deadly.
  2. Read a historical map as evidence: identify patterns in where deaths occurred and form a hypothesis about their cause.
  3. Revise a hypothesis as new evidence is revealed, and explain cases that seem not to fit (exceptions near and far from the source).
  4. Distinguish a correlation (deaths near something) from a cause, and explain what evidence supports a causal claim.
  5. Write a claim naming the source of the outbreak, supported by specific evidence from the map.

Standards covered

StandardWhat students do

Materials

Before class (5 minutes)

Procedure

Times are suggestions for a 50-minute period. Each round button brings that round's evidence onto every map: the deaths (Round 1), the water pumps (Round 2), and the workhouse and brewery (Round 3). The Layers tab is for testing students' own ideas.

Hook and setupabout 5 minutes
Round 1The deaths · 10–12 min
Round 2The water pumps · 10–12 min
Round 3The exceptions · 10–12 min
Wrap-up8–10 min

Student questions

Teacher background and answer key

For the teacher only. Don't share before the class has worked through the evidence.

The source

The Broad Street pump. Deaths cluster tightly around it, and the clearest exceptions point back to its water.

Key evidence, as it appears in the inquiry

What to listen for

Assessment

Model answers (for norming)

Three sample answers to the exit question, "Name the source of the outbreak and give the two strongest pieces of evidence from the map." Use them to calibrate scoring, or have students score them. Written for the game.

Developing: "It was the water pump because a lot of people died there." A claim with one vague piece of evidence and no reasoning.
Proficient: "The Broad Street pump. Most deaths are within a few hundred meters of it, and more deaths fall in its pump neighborhood than any other. The workhouse had its own well and almost no one died, which fits." A clear claim, two specific pieces of map evidence, and an exception explained.
Advanced: "The Broad Street pump. The deaths cluster around it rather than around the sewer vents or the plague pit, which rules out bad air. The outliers fit too: the brewery men drank beer and their own well water, and the Hampstead widow drank Broad Street water carried to her miles away. Deaths were already falling before the handle came off, so removing it proved less than the pattern did." Rules out other theories, uses outliers as support, and weighs the limits of the evidence.

Differentiation

Works cited

© 2026 Isaac Newman. All rights reserved. SimHistory™ is a trademark of Isaac Newman. Teachers may print and copy this plan for their own classes.