SimHistory.org
Free sample · Teacher's guide

Broad Street Inquiry

Your class investigates the 1854 cholera outbreak in Soho, London, using the map evidence Dr. John Snow used. Students propose what to add to the map. You decide which evidence to reveal, round by round, until the class can name the source and prove it.

Try it side by sideOpen the teacher's deskPrintable worksheetDigital answer sheet

Answer sheets. Print the worksheet (no maps, just the questions and room to write), or have students type their answers on the digital answer sheet and download a PDF to hand in, for example on Google Classroom. Answers stay on each student's device.

Spanish on student screens. Each student can tap Español on their own screen to switch the questions, evidence cards, legend and case file to Spanish. Your screen and the projector stay in English, and the evidence is the same in both languages.

Lesson plan. Objectives, standards covered, timing, the answer key and a rubric: download the lesson plan (PDF) or view it.

A 40-second tour: the teacher's desk and a student's screen. Starts muted with captions; turn on the sound to hear the narration.
45–60minutes, one class period
3rounds of worksheet questions
Freeno subscription or student accounts
Three screens

Who sees what

The same game runs on three screens. Only yours has controls. Students never see the list of evidence you can reveal, so their own ideas drive the investigation.

Teacher's desk: the map with Ideas, Layers, Add to map and Answers tabs, the join code and round buttons
Your computer

Teacher's desk

  • The join code and the Round 1–3 buttons
  • Students' ideas as they arrive, merged and counted, each with Reveal buttons
  • Every evidence layer, under Layers
  • Each student's answers and suspect pin, under Answers
Main screen: the map, the join code and the anonymous ideas wall
Projector or smartboard

Main screen

  • The map and evidence cards, following your desk
  • The join code, if you choose
  • The ideas wall, with no student names
  • No controls; open it with Switch this window to projector view
Student screen: the map, the idea box and the round's questions
Each student's device

Student screen

  • The same map you reveal
  • This round's questions; answers save as they type
  • An idea box when you ask (up to 3 ideas)
  • A Mark the source I suspect pin
Running the class

Round by round

  1. Before class5 minutes
    • Open the teacher's desk on your computer. Open the Class menu (next to the join code) for New class, Save game, Open saved game, the class period list and End this game. Each period gets its own game and join code. Games you don't open for a week expire.
    • No projector, or can't show it and your desk at once? You don't need it. Everything you present (the round cards, the layers you reveal, the ideas wall, and any explanation you show) appears on every student's screen as you click it. Your desk stays yours: the map on your desk, labeled What students and the projector see, shows exactly what is on their screens.
    • Click Switch this window to projector view in a second window on the projector. (If you have one.) The pop-up shows how to extend your display on Windows, Mac or Chromebook.
    • Students go to simhistory.org/broadstreet and type the join code and their name. Watch them appear under Answers.
  2. The setup5 minutes
    • Open the Case file on the main screen and read The problem and Cholera basics together. Then go over How to play.
    • Keep it short. The cholera page leaves out how the disease spreads on purpose; that is what the class has to discover.
  3. How rounds and layers workRead this first
    • Each round brings its own evidence. The round buttons add it to every map: the deaths in Round 1, the 13 water pumps in Round 2, and the workhouse and the brewery in Round 3. Your desk shows each round's goal and a question to ask.
    • The Layers tab is for answering students' ideas. When a student suggests something, such as sewers, bad air, an old burial ground, how close, or when, reveal the layer that tests it. That's how the class learns which ideas the evidence supports.
    • Suggested replies. Each student idea on your Ideas tab gets a gold suggested reply when it matches a theory the class can test (bad air, sewers, the plague pit, food, crowding, animals, poverty and more, even misspelled): what you might say to praise it, a button to show it on every map, and what you might explain when the class looks. Show the explanation on the projector puts that explanation beside the map. Only you see the replies.
    • If someone mentions the pumps or the water in Round 1, don't reveal them yet. Say: "Good thought. Hold on to it. We'll come back to that in the next round." Their idea card shows "comes in Round 2" to remind you.
  4. Round 1The deaths
    • The map shows only the deaths. Students answer the three Round 1 questions on their screens.
    • Click Ask the class for ideas. Ideas land privately on your Ideas tab. Hide any you don't want shown, then click Show on main screen to put the anonymous ideas wall up.
    • Talk through the ideas and test them: bad air → sewer vents and gullies; sewage → sewers; disease from the dead → the old plague pit. Use Add as pin for ideas the map doesn't have. Most theories won't fit the cluster, and that's the point.
  5. Round 2The water pumps
    • Click Round 2. The pumps appear on every map, with Round 2's questions.
    • Lead the class to the Broad Street pump. Ask: "Look at where the deaths cluster. Which pump is at the center? How could we test whether that pump is the cause?" Reveal Distance rings or Pump neighborhoods when students ask how close, or which pump is nearest.
    • Have students mark the source they suspect. Turn on Show students' source guesses to see where the class is leaning. By the end of the round, most should point to Broad Street.
  6. Round 3The exceptions
    • Click Round 3. The workhouse and the brewery appear: places right by the pump where almost no one died.
    • Complicate the theory. Ask: "If the Broad Street pump is to blame, why did only 5 of 535 people in the workhouse die, and none of the brewery's 70 workers?" (Both had their own wells, and the brewery men drank beer.) An exception that fits makes the case stronger.
    • Then the deaths on the edges of the map: reveal the percussion cap factory, and the Hampstead widow far away. Round 3's last question asks what Snow should do.
    • In Round 3, students see I'm finished: get my certificate.
  7. Wrap-upThe rest of the story
    • Reveal the evidence under The rest of the story: the cesspool at 40 Broad Street, the percussion-cap factory, the Hampstead widow, and the pump handle's removal on 8 September.
    • Read the answers under Answers, then click New class (or pick the next period in the Class menu) before the next period.
    • Not finished? Click Save game (under the join code) to save the class to your computer. Next time, click Open saved game and students rejoin with the same code. If you're on the same computer and browser, the desk also picks up where you left off by itself.
John Snow's map of cholera deaths around Broad Street, with a black bar for each death
For the wrap-up only: John Snow's own map (2nd ed. of On the Mode of Communication of Cholera, 1855; public domain). Show it after Round 3: it gives the answer away.
An illustration of a Soho street in 1854: a woman draws water at a street pump; a cart and brick houses behind
Soho in 1854: an illustration made for SimHistory, not a historical picture. Also for after the inquiry; it shows a pump.
Broadwick Street today, with a white silhouette replica of the Broad Street pump
The street today, with a replica of the pump. Photograph: Wellcome Collection, Public Domain Mark.

First time? Try it side by side to play the teacher and a student at the same time before class. It takes about five minutes.